The Books of the Year feature in newspapers and periodicals
is so widespread that Private Eye produces its own satirical version. I used to
be wildly enthusiastic about seeing what the great and the good had listed as
their favourite books, until I began to notice how reviewers tended to
recommend each other’s books, and, equally fundamentally, how little the
reviewers actually said of the books they were recommending that provided any
evidence that they had actually read them, or to convince me in turn to read
them.
A third challenge is the sheer number of books some
reviewers claim to have read, along with their willingness to praise
extravagantly titles that will I am sure be forgotten in five years. Martin
Wolf of The Financial Times, for example, seems to recommend more newly
published books (14) than titles of any publication date that I have read this
year. If these are the books he recommends as his Books of the Year, how many
others did he read and not recommend? For my own reading, I would happy indeed
to enjoy one book for every three I start reading – which would mean, for Mr
Wolf, he started reading over 40 books, an unlikely figure. And it’s not only
the quantity – Mr Wolf appears to like wholeheartedly each of the 14 books he
recommends, which is impressive, given that they are all covering present-day
economics. Do all these books agree with each other? Can you like them all?
Given the above qualifications, here are my books of 2025.
My rule is the books I have read this year, not books published this year.
Publishers, who are interested in front lists for commercial reasons, want to
sell what they have just published, but I am under no such constraint. Outrageously,
I see the FT also publishes a separate list of books by FT authors published
this year. I reserve the right to add a list of my own, although it will be
rather short – zero, in fact.
Going back to Martin Wolf’s recommendations, he benefits
from the journalist’s privilege: he can recommend any number of conflicting
titles that would contradict each other in many ways if examined closely, yet
as a journalist, you are not obliged to maintain consistency in books of the
year; you can say they are all great books. I would hope to be somewhat more
critical. For me, disliking a book can be constructive, if it helps you engage
more with the subject.
So, with all those caveats, here is a list of 14 books I have read, or read an appreciable portion of, this year (there is no need to read a book in its entirety to have an opinion on it). It’s a sign of my indolence that several of these books I have read without, it seems, any comment, or at least, any public comment.
- The Anarchy (William Dalrymple) (with a mention of The Golden Road, also by Dalrymple)
- The History Man (Malcolm Bradbury)
- Sea People (Christina Thompson)
- How Life Works (Philip Ball)
- In Diamond Square (Rodoreda)
- The Museum of Other People (Adam Kuper)
- The Switch (Elmore Leonard)
- Longitude (Dava Sobel)
- The Age of Innocence (Wharton)
- City Life (Rybczinski)
- Something Fresh (P G Wodehouse)
- Finding Longitude
- Boswell in Holland (a volume of Boswell’s journals)
The Anarchy
This must be my book of the year. In a sentence, it gave a
warts-and-all of the almost accidental nature of the British conquest of India,
and the incredible enrichment of some of those involved in it (Robert Clive,
specifically).
In a podcast interview, William Dalrymple revealed how
surprised he was that many people in India buy his books, particularly The
Golden Road. But I can’t help thinking that much of what he writes about
India has a balance to it that, when we read it, we feel has been what we were
waiting for. After reading Macaulay and any number of historians following,
consciously or otherwise, heroic assumptions about the British in India, it was
riveting to read about how the East India Company had more power than many
governments, how Robert Clive was able to amass the greatest private collection
of Indian art, and how it can still be seen in Powis Castle. Not only can
Dalrymple tell a good story, he uses art and literature to excellent effect,
even in a cheap paperback where, for reasons best known to the publisher, the
illustrations are not linked to any specific point in the text.
The History Man (Malcolm Bradbury)
This comic novel, from 1975, shows its date, in its wildly
politically incorrect story of a philandering lecturer at a new university. His
behaviour would get him sacked today, on multiple counts, but, as with Jim
Dixon in Kingsley Amis’ Lucky Jim, we read on astonished by the
outrageousness of Howard Kirk’s relationships with his students (and fellow
lecturers). Just one question: Kirk is a social science lecturer, so where is
the history? Probably Howard Kirk would be seen today as history – even from
the context of Bradbury’s own time.
Sea People I wrote
about in May; How Life Works
in September. In Diamond Square (La Placa del Diamant) is a Catalan
novel set during the Spanish Civil War, and made for very uncomfortable
reading. Orwell communicated well the feeling of being caught up in something
difficult to comprehend, but Merce Rodoreda’s characters are locked into a
struggle of which they have little comprehension. These are the people whose
lives are changed forever by the War, yet the politics and leaders are barely
glimpsed.

No comments:
Post a Comment